The Reality Check
Companies are mandating office returns, but the results aren't matching expectations. While organizations have increased office requirements by 12% since early 2024, employees continue working from home about 25% of the time. This disconnect between policy and practice is creating real business challenges that need practical solutions.
Current Market Dynamics
Work Forward's analysis of 9,000 employers shows companies have increased office requirements by 12% since early 2024. However, Stanford economist Nicholas Bloom's surveys reveal that Americans continue working from home approximately 25% of the time—the same level as 2023.
Major corporations like Microsoft, Paramount, NBCUniversal, Amazon, Dell, and JPMorgan have implemented increasingly strict attendance requirements. Yet as the Wall Street Journal reports, "Big companies...are ordering workers to show up to the office more often. If only their staffs would heed the call."
The WSJ Problem: "Companies Are Struggling to Enforce Mandates"
Problem 1: Managers Don't Want to Enforce Rules
The Wall Street Journal found that "many managers tasked with herding folks into the office would rather not be there either." Tech HR executive Beth Steinberg explains: "There's a lot more pressing things for companies to be worrying about right now." When it comes to high performers breaking attendance rules, "I haven't heard of many consequences for that, especially if somebody's a high-performer."
How Atteniv Solves This: Our platform removes the burden from managers by automating attendance tracking and compliance workflows. Managers no longer need to play "attendance police"—the system handles monitoring, documentation, and escalation automatically, letting managers focus on what matters most.
Problem 2: Companies Can't Actually Track Who's Following the Rules
The WSJ reports that most companies "don't put in the effort to catch shirkers by matching up badge swipes, Wi-Fi connections, time-off schedules and other data." This makes it "hard to distinguish rule-breakers from those out sick or traveling for work, so many HR departments dig deeper only if workers miss at least half of their required days."
How Atteniv Solves This: We integrate with your existing endpoint security systems (ZScaler, Fortinet, Microsoft Endpoint Defender) to automatically track real office presence versus brief appearances. No additional hardware needed, and we can distinguish between legitimate absences and policy violations without manual effort.
Problem 3: "Logistical Snags" Are Real and Expensive
Amazon "ran short on desks, parking and videoconferencing rooms after ordering hundreds of thousands of workers to the office full time" and had to backpedal in Houston, New York, and elsewhere. Dell faced similar problems.
How Atteniv Solves This: Our analytics show you actual space utilization patterns, helping you optimize office layouts and capacity planning. Instead of guessing how much space you need, you get real data about peak usage times, popular areas, and underutilized spaces. This prevents costly over-commitment and helps you right-size your real estate footprint.
Problem 4: The "Stealth Layoff" Effect Backfires
The WSJ notes that "tighter requirements sometimes precede or follow layoff announcements." The Federal Reserve observed that employers are "reducing head counts through attrition—encouraged, at times, by return-to-office policies." But as Stanford's Bloom warns: "It is a cheap way to reduce head count, there's no disguising that. The problem is, you don't get to choose who leaves."
How Atteniv Solves This: Rather than using attendance as a blunt instrument, our platform provides performance-integrated data that helps you make informed decisions about who should be in the office when, and why. You can create policies based on actual business needs rather than arbitrary mandates, reducing the risk of losing your best performers.
Additional WSJ Insights and Atteniv Solutions
The Compliance Reality
The Wall Street Journal found that companies requiring three or more days in office see compliance fall below 75%, according to CBRE data. Meanwhile, nearly half of senior managers told BambooHR they'd take a pay cut to work from home, creating built-in resistance to enforcement.
Atteniv's Approach: Instead of rigid mandates that create adversarial relationships, our platform enables flexible policies with clear accountability. You can set business-driven attendance requirements while automatically handling exceptions and accommodations, creating fairness without micromanagement.
The Geographic Reality Check
The WSJ notes that while some areas like New York City (with financial firms pushing full-time office return) show higher subway and foot traffic, "nationally, office visits in August were down by about a third from 2019." Most smaller companies continue allowing remote work as routine.
Atteniv's Advantage: Our analytics help you understand your specific situation rather than following industry-wide trends. Whether you're in a major financial center or a distributed organization, you get data tailored to your workforce patterns, locations, and business needs.
Why Traditional Monitoring Fails
As the WSJ article highlights, most companies aren't equipped to handle the complexity of modern attendance tracking. Badge swipes don't tell the full story, WiFi connections can be spoofed, and correlating time-off schedules with actual presence requires manual effort most HR departments can't sustain.
Atteniv's Technical Edge: By integrating with endpoint security systems your organization already uses, we provide accurate presence detection without additional infrastructure. We automatically correlate multiple data sources to distinguish between legitimate absences (sick days, business travel, approved remote work) and policy violations.
Real Business Impact
The WSJ reports that some companies are using RTO mandates as "stealth layoffs," but as Stanford's Bloom emphasizes, "you don't get to choose who leaves." Organizations lose valuable employees who refuse rigid return-to-office requirements while potentially retaining less productive workers who simply comply with location requirements.
Atteniv's Strategic Value: Our platform helps you make attendance decisions based on business outcomes rather than blanket policies. You can identify which roles truly require in-person collaboration, which employees are most productive in different settings, and how to structure policies that retain top performers while meeting legitimate business needs.
Implementation Without the Conflict
The WSJ article demonstrates that current approaches create workplace tension, management burden, and operational inefficiency. Companies need solutions that address the legitimate business needs driving RTO mandates while respecting the workplace flexibility employees have come to expect.
Atteniv provides the framework for organizations to navigate this transition intelligently, with data-driven policies, automated compliance management, and balanced accountability that works for both employers and employees.
Ready to move beyond the mandate struggle? Discover how Atteniv's intelligent approach can solve your return-to-office challenges while maintaining employee trust and organizational efficiency.
Stay Updated
Sign up for our newsletter to be notified of the official Atteniv launch and receive more insights on secure access solutions for hybrid work environments.
References
Francis, T. (2025, September 21). The Rush to Return to the Office Is Stalling. The Wall Street Journal.
Work Forward. (2025). Workplace policy analysis of 9,000 employers.
Bloom, N. (2025). Stanford ongoing survey of remote work patterns among 10,000 Americans.
BambooHR. (2025). Survey of 1,500 salaried U.S. employees including 500 HR professionals.
CBRE. (2025). Survey on office attendance compliance rates.
Federal Reserve. (2025, August). Economic update on employer workforce strategies.
publishedAt: "2025-09-24"